Südtirol

In the early ‘90s came the idea to bring professional football back to South Tyrol, because since the ‘80s with FC Bolzano, no South Tyrolean team played in a professional league. Negotiations for the takeover of FC Bolzano, which was in financial difficulties, failed. A South Tyrolean entrepreneurial group then took over SV Milland, founded in 1974 and based in a district of Brixen, which played before the acquisition in the season 1994/95 in the regional Eccellenza, but was relegated after that season into the Promozione.

1995-2000: In the amateur leagues

The team was renamed FC Südtirol–Alto Adige in 1995; Alto Adige is the Italian name of the province while Südtirol is its German indigenous name. The club started its first season in 1995 in the regional Promozione (then still the seventh-highest league in Italy). Immediate promotion to the Eccellenza was achieved via a first place finish. From the 1997/98 season, the club played in the national league Serie D (V). Each season, the FC Südtirol was able to improve. In 2000, then under coach Giuseppe Sannino, it was promoted to Serie C2 (IV), the lowest professional league.

2000–2010: FC Südtirol in Serie C2 (IV)

In 2000, the company incorporated as Fußballclub Südtirol S.r.l., thus becoming F.C. Südtirol and relocating to Bolzano^[] (though it was legally based in Brixen until 2011). The club was able to establish itself quickly in the professional league. The aim of the club was to achieve promotion into Serie C1 as soon as possible. The team failed in the following seasons each time in the play-offs. FC Südtirol got into financial difficulties and then focused more on youth work.
Just before the end of the season 2008/09, youth coach Alfredo Sebastiani took over the first team. With him, the club avoided relegation in the play-outs against Valenzana Calcio. Under Sebastiani, the team in 2009/10 reached for the first time promotion to Serie C1 (III), by finishing the season in first place.

2010 to today: from Serie C to the second division

In the 2010–11 Lega Pro Prima Divisione season, Südtirol was relegated to Lega Pro Seconda Divisione after the relegation "play-out", but on 4 August 2011 was readmitted to Lega Pro Prima Divisione to fill vacancies.

In the next season, the club hired Giovanni Stroppa, who was at that time youth coach of Milan. The team was able to establish itself in the third tier and narrowly missed the promotion play-offs. With good performances, players like Manuel Fischnaller and Alessandro Iacobucci moved to the Serie B. After the season Stroppa became Coach of the Serie A club Pescara.

In the 2012–13 Lega Pro Prima Divisione season, the team was coached by Stefano Vecchi. With him the team was able to reach the promotion playoffs of the Italian third tier for the first time in club history. In the play-off semi-final the team was eliminated by Carpi, which eventually won promotion. In the following season, Vecchi was hired by Carpi.

The 2013–14 season started with Lorenzo D'Anna as coach, previously youth coach of Chievo. Under him, the team could score only five points in the first five matches, which was not enough for the promotion ambitions of the club. They changed coaches and hired Claudio Rastelli. During the championship, the team was able to prevail better and in the end reached third place in the table. That was the best result of the club's history and the repeated achievement of the play-offs. In the quarterfinals, the team prevailed against Como on penalties. In the semi-final, Cremonese was defeated over two legs. The final round for promotion to Serie B was lost against Pro Vercelli.

Südtirol's 2021–22 season turned out to be the most successful in club history, as they won the title race on the final matchday, with a five-point advantage to runners-up Padova, and also reached the 2021–22 Coppa Italia Serie C final, losing on aggregate to Padova. Therefore they acquired their place in the Serie B for the 2022–23 season, which was to be both Südtirol's first time in the league, as well as the very first time a club from Südtirol/Alto Adige qualified for a spot in the Italian second division.

The 2022-23 season turned out to be an even bigger success for Südtirol. While losing their first three league matches and suffering an embarrassing early knockout from the Coppa Italia on home turf against Serie C opponent Feralpisalò, the team quickly picked up the pace of the league and were in constant contention for promotion to Serie A, either directly or via play-offs. A late campaign blow to their form meant that Südtirol clinched 6th place in the league with 58 points, which meant they qualified to the promotion play-off preliminary round, coming 15 points short of directly promoted Genoa's 73 points in second place, and only two points short of play-off semi-final qualifiers Parma in fourth place.

The preliminary play-off round saw Südtirol hosting Reggina in a one-match showdown, where Pierpaolo Bisoli's squad managed to clinch a nail-biting 1-0 victory with a late Daniele Casiraghi goal in the 89th minute to advance into the semi-finals where they met 3rd place finishers Bari in a two-match pairing. On home turf, Südtirol managed to win with an even more late goal by Matteo Rover in the 90+2nd minute to put Südtirol in the lead. The second leg saw Südtirol being one man up in the San Nicola after a first half red card on behalf of Bari, but a 70th minute Leonardo Benedetti goal meant that Bari equalized the aggregate score, which meant that Südtirol got eliminated as the higher regular season finish is used as a tiebreaker.